Taken Aback 

Women's-rights advocates take their message to the grounds of the State Capitol and find a stunning display of force.

click to enlarge Seemingly unfazed by the police, Iris English attended the protest with her mother, Lynn English. - Scott Elmquist
  • Scott Elmquist
  • Seemingly unfazed by the police, Iris English attended the protest with her mother, Lynn English.

From outside the Bell Tower in Capitol Square, during their march along Broad Street past the National Theater, the federal courthouse and back again, a mass of protesters chant: "Not the church, not the state. Women must decide their fate."

By now it's likely that you've seen the images, headlines and news accounts of the weekend protest, which starts silently and devolves into police officers wearing riot gear and body shields and wielding rifles and cans of mace.

But the thousand or so protesters don't back down. They keep chanting, they lock arms and many of them refuse to budge from the south steps of the Capitol because, as one observer puts it, "they were tired of begging for their rights."

Slideshow
Women's Rights Protest at the Virginia Capitol, March 3, 2012
Women's Rights Protest at the Virginia Capitol, March 3, 2012 Women's Rights Protest at the Virginia Capitol, March 3, 2012 Women's Rights Protest at the Virginia Capitol, March 3, 2012 Women's Rights Protest at the Virginia Capitol, March 3, 2012 Women's Rights Protest at the Virginia Capitol, March 3, 2012 Women's Rights Protest at the Virginia Capitol, March 3, 2012 Women's Rights Protest at the Virginia Capitol, March 3, 2012 Women's Rights Protest at the Virginia Capitol, March 3, 2012

Women's Rights Protest at the Virginia Capitol, March 3, 2012

By Scott Elmquist

Click to View 23 slides

In Virginia's new political landscape, where the Republican-controlled General Assembly can muscle through legislation requiring any woman seeking an abortion to receive an ultrasound procedure, these are the front-line dissenters in a culture war that in the span of two weeks went from cold to hot. By the end of the day, 30 protesters are arrested and taken to jail.

The March 3 rally ends a contentious two weeks in the statehouse, with anti-abortion legislation generating national headlines and late-night comedians riffing on government-mandated transvaginal probes.

Legislation granting "personhood" status to children from the moment of conception was shelved until next year — it was thought. On Monday as Style Weekly was going to press, the General Assembly seemed to be considering a lesser form of the legislation. A bill requiring probing ultrasounds was amended, requiring only abdominal ultrasounds prior to abortions.

There was no clean exit to the debate, and frustrations couldn't be bottled up so easily. They needed someplace to go, someplace to be heard.

They go to the State Capitol.

Estimates from the organizers, Speak Loudly with Silence, put the number of attendees at around 1,000. They're both young and old. Female, mostly. Their three-hour demonstration is filled with chants and speeches.

After being warned to vacate the south steps of the Capitol, 30 people — about half of them men, half of them women — are arrested on charges ranging from unlawful assembly to trespassing, according to Capitol Police.

The tactics are familiar. So are some of the faces. You might remember some from Kanawha Plaza. Or Monroe Park. Many of those arrested were participants in the Occupy Richmond movement that for almost two weeks parked illegally in the downtown plaza, then moved to Richmond Free Press Publisher Ray Boone's front yard, next door to Mayor Dwight Jones.

One of them, Claire Tuite, says that Saturday's arrests weren't planned. When the protesters emerge on the Capitol, some of them make an "autonomous decision" to "occupy" the steps of the Capitol. "This was a peaceful protest on taxpayer-funded property," Tuite says. "We have every right to be here."

Molly Vice, press liaison for the group, says the arrests "shames lawmakers for passing regressive legislation that usurps the good judgment of women on their own health care for the state's."

"It's an outrage," she says of the ultrasound bill. "We're here ... to tell truth to power that infringing on women's health is not OK. Not this year or the next."

By Monday, the 30 people who were arrested are released, but after the weekend rowdiness that led to mayhem, and the countless photos invoking Vietnam-era police confrontations, Richmond can't seem to shake its increasingly repressive reputation. Democratic lawmakers blamed the protest and the arrests on Gov. Bob McDonnell and the GOP's social-activist lawmakers, and their agenda. Some, such as state Sen. Janet Howell, D-Fairfax, liken the police response to the protest to that of the 1960s, during Massive Resistance.

"Our State Capitol is becoming an armed garrison," Howell laments.

In all likelihood, the officers called into duty on Saturday are just as apprehensive about the confrontation. They at times seem reluctant, hesitant, unwilling, but ultimately there to do a job. And that the protesters don't back down may be a testament to something else: Sometimes, we really do stand up and fight for what we believe in, no matter the consequences.

As of Monday, the governor hadn't issued a public statement about Saturday's events, though he was scheduled for a news conference on the eve of Super Tuesday to recommend that voters cast their ballots for presidential candidate Mitt Romney.

The headlines will fade, and the furor will die down soon enough. But the chants will echo in the online videos, the images, the newspaper stories, for months to come.

"Tell me what democracy looks like," they call out.

"This is what democracy looks like."

Comments (5)

Showing 1-5 of 5

Add a comment

 
Subscribe to this thread:
Showing 1-5 of 5

Add a comment

"Play On"

The story of a theater group trying desperately to put on a...

Teen Talent

A night when talented teens demonstrate works of spoken word, monologue, song,...

View all of today's events

  • Re: Will Reggae Singer's Bottle Attack Scar Richmond's Reputation?

    • How much do I get paid and does the date/routing work? The rest is noise.

    • on May 23, 2013
  • Re: Will Reggae Singer's Bottle Attack Scar Richmond's Reputation?

    • Well there are a lot of reasons for a band to come or not come…

    • on May 23, 2013
  • Re: Will Reggae Singer's Bottle Attack Scar Richmond's Reputation?

    • Maybe it's just me but I suspect that this is just going to be another…

    • on May 23, 2013
  • More »
  • Facebook Recommendations

    Latest in Cover Story

    • 2013 Best of Richmond

      Let the judging begin. Richmond weighs in with our annual survey, plus a few choices of our own.
      • May 21, 2013
    • Rocking the River

      Meet five Richmond athletes who get their thrills beyond the gym.
      • May 14, 2013
    • Street Smarting

      Why the city's most famous outlaw muralist went corporate for art's sake.
      • May 7, 2013
    • More »

    More by Scott Elmquist

    Copyright © 2013 Style Weekly
    Richmond's alternative for news, arts, culture and opinion
    All rights reserved
    Powered by Foundation