The Grub Next Door 

The Mill on MacArthur is a neighborhood joint.

click to enlarge House-made potato chips give extra flavor and value to the Kickin' Chicken sandwich at the Mill on MacArthur. - SCOTT ELMQUIST
  • Scott Elmquist
  • House-made potato chips give extra flavor and value to the Kickin' Chicken sandwich at the Mill on MacArthur.

On the first visit, a member of the wait staff at the Mill at MacArthur doesn't show, creating chaos on the floor and a noticeable backup in the kitchen. Not a problem. A Lost Coast tangerine ale is consumed from the well-rounded beer list and a vow is made to return.

Next visit, a long wait for a table would have pushed our meal time well into late night. No worries, a Genesee Cream Ale, another vow to return. Third time's a charm, right? No. A power outage. Restaurant is down for the night.

One more beer, one more vow. Things are starting to get comical.

The restaurant is a small place with tables lining every wall. Owned and operated by a former Star-Lite Dining and Lounge manager and current Mojo's owners, the cafe's design shows their experience. Chalkboards announce the beer lists and daily specials. A long bar at the back of the restaurant is comfortable and utilitarian. Dishes are sturdy; silverware is recycled. The menu consists primarily of sandwiches with a few pizza choices and entrees. It's a consistently busy, family-friendly place.

The hummus platter ($7) is perfectly OK. The addition of basil gives freshness to the lumpy chickpea mixture, and the peperoncini, jarred red pepper slices and crumbled feta are welcome and create a colorful presentation. From the all-day breakfast menu, my eggs are adequately scrambled; the sausage is an average diner patty. The potato cake is mushy but has great potential with a little more seasoning and crispness. The Philly cheese steak is average, with a gooey texture that's off-putting but shows effort from the kitchen. Boardwalk fries are excellent in theory but arrive limp without any of the hoped-for crunchiness. Onion rings are bland.

Many families are eating pizza so I try the Four Seasons ($13). Overly cheesed, garlicky and tomato pasty, it has a sweet, doughy crust. Canned artichoke hearts, conch pieces, reconstituted mushrooms and broccoletti sit atop this confused but mostly adequate pie.

But the restaurant has a stellar side. A kickin' chicken sandwich ($8) is lively with spice and creative with the addition of pea shoots. The Angus burger ($9) is cooked to request and the bacon is crispy. The house-made potato chips are the only side that doesn't cost extra and is the best of the offerings, especially with a little more salt.

The children's menu has the old standbys — chicken tenders, personal pizzas, grilled cheeses — all priced at $6. There's a little area designated specifically for the kids with coloring materials and books. Service is jovial and chatty. Desserts are made in-house and the Key lime pie is among the best I've had in Richmond; at two for $1.50, the chocolate-chip cookies are sure to please little ones.

While I don't think the Mill is knocking anyone's socks off, it's a filling and familiar option for neighbors and appears to be meeting a need. S

The Mill on MacArthur
4023 MacArthur Ave.
Open daily 10 a.m.-10 p.m.


Speaking of...

Comments (17)

Showing 1-17 of 17

Add a comment

Subscribe to this thread:
Showing 1-17 of 17

Add a comment

  • Re: Almost All of the Doughnuts at Sugar Shack Are Now Vegan

    • Oh yeah! I hope they spread nationwide. LOVE vegan donuts!

    • on August 10, 2017
  • Re: Almost All of the Doughnuts at Sugar Shack Are Now Vegan

    • I wonder if the location on Hugeunot Rd is on this bandwagon, too? I sure…

    • on August 9, 2017
  • Re: Drinking History: The Virginia Historical Society Throws Its First Craft Beer Festival

    • Sounds like a great event! Right up Richmond's alley. Looking forward to attending next year.

    • on August 9, 2017
  • More »
  • More by Robey Martin

    • 2015 State of the Plate

      2015 State of the Plate

      Favorite dishes, unsung heroes and the rise of hospitality in Richmond. Plus, why our Restaurant of the Year is Metzger Bar & Butchery.
      • Mar 10, 2015
    • Single-Minded Focus

      Single-Minded Focus

      The old Phil's Continental Lounge will transform into Jack Brown's Beer & Burger Joint in March.
      • Feb 20, 2015
    • Noodles Galore

      Noodles Galore

      Spiral Noodle is slated for opening this spring in the old Yapple spot.
      • Feb 19, 2015
    • More »

    Copyright © 2017 Style Weekly
    Richmond's alternative for news, arts, culture and opinion
    All rights reserved
    Powered by Foundation