Shamrock Brawl Investigation to Stay Private 

click to enlarge The Richmond Police Department declines to release details from its investigation into an altercation between an officer and a partygoer at the Shamrock the Block Festival in Shockoe Bottom.
  • The Richmond Police Department declines to release details from its investigation into an altercation between an officer and a partygoer at the Shamrock the Block Festival in Shockoe Bottom.

He's YouTube famous. And as of Friday, Jason M. Dotson of Colonial Heights also has been charged with felony assault on a police officer for his part in a St. Patrick's Day brawl captured on video and watched 170,000 times.

As for how officers handled the incident, Richmond police spokesman Gene Lepley confirms that the department won't be releasing the results of an internal affairs investigation.

Video of the fight at the Shamrock the Block Festival on March 16 appears to show a police officer repeatedly push and choke the 22-year-old. They end up wrestling on the ground before two other officers step in. The department didn't identify any of the officers.

"It's a personnel matter," Lepley says. "We just don't speak to it." Likewise, the results of any internal investigation are exempt from public disclosure as private personnel records under Virginia's Freedom of Information Act.

Sparking debate and dividing residents, the video of the fight simultaneously provoked cries of police brutality and praise that the officer showed great restraint.

In emails to Style Weekly, some people who think the officer overreacted wondered whether the department would conduct a fair investigation. They noted the department's actions on social media the day the video went viral.

Communications staff used the Richmond Police Department's Facebook page to "like" supportive comments posted by residents. Garnering official Richmond police approval were missives such as: "I watched both videos and I support the RPD! Good Work!!" The department ignored less sympathetic opinions.

Lepley says communications staff has no interaction with the internal affairs unit, so actions on Facebook aren't indicative of how the department is handling the investigation.

Lauri Stevens, a law enforcement communications consultant based in Boston, says the Richmond Police Department has an extremely active Facebook presence and is known as a leader in police use of social media. But, she says, "we are all still learning."

Stevens says the general perception is that it's the department as a whole making comments when the reality is that it's one person making a judgment call.

"I would have advised them to make a statement on their Facebook page … thanking everyone for their input but [saying] they're not allowed to comment further," Stevens says. "That would have satisfied their desire to not ignore their followers but also not jeopardize any relationships or the case."



Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

  • Re: The Brain-Makers

    • Hi everyone, this is good news, a perfect and greats one. My daughter of 17years…

    • on September 22, 2017
  • Re: Need a Flu Shot? The Richmond Health District Is Offering Them for Free on Oct. 6.

    • somebody has to be paying for it ???

    • on September 22, 2017
  • Re: How Jim Crow Codified the Bigotry Already Woven Into the Fabric of Virginia

    • Vincent, although Booker T. Washington was a very brilliant man he was criticized during his…

    • on September 21, 2017
  • More »
  • More by Ned Oliver

    • Auto Spying

      Auto Spying

      Virginia lawmakers are fighting against the use of license-plate scanners by police. But what about the people privately watching your whereabouts?
      • Apr 28, 2015
    • City Explores Tax on Richmond Airbnb Rentals

      City Explores Tax on Richmond Airbnb Rentals

      • Apr 21, 2015
    • Flash Forward

      Flash Forward

      Richmond is getting a $54 million, high-speed bus line right down Broad Street. But do we need it? Here are the answers to seven questions you might be asking.
      • Apr 21, 2015
    • More »

    Copyright © 2017 Style Weekly
    Richmond's alternative for news, arts, culture and opinion
    All rights reserved
    Powered by Foundation