Seeking Salvation for City's "Crappy Farmers' Market" 

click to enlarge Business at the 17th Street Farmers' Market has been declining steadily. Now, some community activists want an overhaul. - SCOTT ELMQUIST
  • Scott Elmquist
  • Business at the 17th Street Farmers' Market has been declining steadily. Now, some community activists want an overhaul.

Change its name. Play some music. Start a shuttle service.

Those were some of the suggestions that came out of last week's community meeting on the future of the city-owned 17th Street Farmers' Market.

The outdoor market is one of the nation's oldest, dating to the 1700s. But it's in a slump. Foot traffic is lower than ever, the market's Shockoe Bottom neighbors report.

People compare 17th Street to wildly successful ventures such as the South of the James Market and think, "Oh, it's a crappy farmers' market," says Rick Tatnall, the meeting organizer and founder of Replenish Richmond.

The market began floundering just as a veritable food revolution led to a renaissance in farmers' markets throughout the city in the mid-2000s. The market is managed by the city's Economic Development Department, which has seen 15 directors over the last 15 years. New director Lee Downey was hired in mid-April, filling a post that had been vacant since September 2009.

Lacking management stability, the multiple development proposals that have been floated for the market over the years — including enclosing it and adding condos — failed to gain any traction.

But 17th Street shouldn't be viewed as a failed farmer's market, Tatnall says. It can become an event venue and a tourist draw. To capitalize on its history, some people suggested reclaiming the market's original name: First Market Square.

The big question, Tatnall says, is how can the market grab the increasing number of residents moving into the neighborhood? He thinks a combination of diverse vendors and events might be the answer: specifically, more food and drink events such as the Shockoe Tomato (July 23) and Brunswick Stew (Nov. 5) festivals. "You have a venue here," he says. "Start doing them, immediately."

Event promoter Matt Davey has been running the RVA River Jam, a DJ series, on the Canal Walk on summer Saturday afternoons. "It's slowly catching on, starting to get some attention," he says. Davey wants to organize events that connect the canal's Turning Basin with the market, as "two city centers for entertainment and tourism."

The market also could be a doorway to the newly marked Slave Trail, Tatnall says. An inexpensive taxi ride, or a shuttle bus, could take visitors to the start of the trail at the Manchester Docks.

Whether these ideas are possible may depend on the new Shockoe Bottom study the city has commissioned. It's supposed to be presented to city officials in the next few weeks (see last week's cover story, "Raising the Bottom," at Styleweekly.com). The one thing that's sure, Tatnall observes, is that the Bottom won't get a stadium or a slavery museum anytime soon. "So we just have to use what we got."


Latest in News and Features

Comments (13)

Showing 1-13 of 13

Add a comment

Subscribe to this thread:
Showing 1-13 of 13

Add a comment

Connect with Style Weekly

Most Popular Stories

  • Cars, Horses and Children

    Cars, Horses and Children

    A Valentine exhibition uses the work of amateur photographer Edith Shelton to shine a light on Richmond neighborhoods of the ’50s through the ’70s.
    • Jan 19, 2021
  • Cajun Adventures

    Cajun Adventures

    Former Richmonder Ann Savoy publishes her second major work about Cajun, Creole and zydeco music.
    • Jan 12, 2021
  • Richmonder of the Year

    Richmonder of the Year

    After a global pandemic stopped everything, Dr. Danny TK Avula was the right person at the right time.
    • Dec 29, 2020
  • Rehabbing Big Brown

    Rehabbing Big Brown

    Our architecture critic looks at why to rehab the existing Richmond Coliseum and make it a centerpiece for redevelopment.
    • Jan 12, 2021
  • More »

Copyright © 2021 Style Weekly
Richmond's alternative for news, arts, culture and opinion
All rights reserved
Powered by Foundation