Favorite

Jury Foreman, Lawler Neighbor Recalls Case 

I thoroughly enjoyed your article on Ed Lawler (“The Curious Case of John Edward Lawler,” Cover Story, June 17), but not the memory of the murder. I was both a neighbor on Riverside Drive and the foreman of the Johnny Ballard jury trial.

My contact with Lawler was minimal — his dog would escape to my home and jump into my truck to sleep. I returned him several times. Even though I divulged this information to the lawyers I was never stricken from the jury. Mike Morchower asked me why, and years later I asked Ballard attorney Craig Cooley in the Richmond Airport. He had asked if I were involved in youth programs — I was a volunteer baseball coach in Huguenot Little League for 7 years. I answered yes and that's why I was not stricken. The defense reasoned that I would be opposed to capital punishment of a 17-year-old. They were correct. But the entire jury felt the same way. We all felt [Carl G.] Simons was the real “bludgeoner.”

One discrepancy from what the jury was told and what Simons says in the article — Simons needed money for back child support and Juanita Mae Ballard suggested Lawler as a source, to avoid Simons going to jail or other legal ramifications — the rest is history.
Frank D. Carpin
Richmond

Favorite

Comments

Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

Connect with Style Weekly

Most Popular Stories

  • No Context Needed

    No Context Needed

    We owe it to the children of Linwood Holton Elementary to remove the nearby monument to A.P. Hill, a Confederate general.
    • Feb 25, 2020
  • Week of February 26

    Week of February 26

    • Feb 26, 2020
  • OPINION: Love Wins

    OPINION: Love Wins

    We must pass the Virginia Values Act to make discrimination against LGBTQ people illegal.
    • Feb 25, 2020
  • OPINION: Navy Hill: What Went Wrong?

    OPINION: Navy Hill: What Went Wrong?

    A majority of City Council believes that Richmonders want the city to focus on our biggest problems.
    • Feb 4, 2020
  • More »

Copyright © 2020 Style Weekly
Richmond's alternative for news, arts, culture and opinion
All rights reserved
Powered by Foundation