Burger Roulette 

Six rounds of Richmond's better burgers.

click to enlarge The Ivy Mill burger at Honey Whyte’s in Shockoe Bottom has a crusty sear to contrast with melted cheese. - SCOTT ELMQUIST
  • Scott Elmquist
  • The Ivy Mill burger at Honey Whyte’s in Shockoe Bottom has a crusty sear to contrast with melted cheese.

While Richmond seems to have lost all restraint for the budget drive-through Cook-Out burger and its harrowingly dangerous-for-pedestrians layout, some of the city’s better burgers might get lost in the smoky haze. Here are some lesser-known burger favorites in a town — and country — that puts one on nearly every restaurant menu.

Honey Whyte’s
The Honey Whyte’s burger ($5 quarter-pound, $7 half-pound) is big and messy. My medium-rare burger is seared with an almost crustlike exterior. I chose white American and jalapenos to dress mine, but the wealth of toppings offered won’t hem you in. The size makes you think you’ll be unable to finish — but the taste will push you to the greasy delicious last bite.

2116 E Main St.

A bit of a wait in a slightly smoky dinner space yields a Bubba burger, and not the Sam’s Club kind. Prices are well under the norm at $4.95 for a half-pounder with chips. The huge, misshapen patty is definitely made for two, and the double Bubba could feed a small army for $6.95. If the vehicle (bun) and toppings (lettuce, tomato, onion) had a little more pep in their step, it would be one of the best I tried.

4000 E. Williamsburg Road

Bamboo Cafe
The beef is 6 ounces of unadulterated (none needed) ground meat, $6.25 with chips. The well-composed result is lively with fresh tomatoes, sweet white onion and leaf lettuce. Served on a soft roll, it’s a perfect, no-frills, garden-bright, eat-in or take-out burger.

1 S. Mulberry St.

Parks Combo
I know it’s a frozen patty on a seasoned griddle, but it tastes so good I almost feel dirty for eating it. Generous portions of cheese, bacon and meat are packaged with shredded lettuce and paper-thin slices of tomato. It’s the quintessential “fast food” burger except it isn’t. For $3.33, it’s worth every penny.

100 E. Brookland Park Blvd.

Roxy Café
A friend suggests Roxy’s $6.15 burger. After a bit of unfounded trepidation I’m pleasantly surprised by the well-cooked patty. Made to order and liberally dressed, the burger is cheesy, peppery and satisfying. If you aren’t into loud and fun-loving college students, get it to go.

1104 W. Main St.

Poe’s Pub
The new chef at Poe’s has a hand for beef. For $7, including hand-cut fries, this outstanding unprocessed 7-ouncer is hand-formed and expertly grilled. Hefty cheese slices and an abundance of fluffy bun occasionally overwhelm a delicately seasoned bite. I suggest bacon (50 cents) as a must have. It’s thickly sliced, ample and crispy.

2706 E. Main St.


Comments (3)

Showing 1-3 of 3

Add a comment

Subscribe to this thread:
Showing 1-3 of 3

Add a comment

  • Re: Almost All of the Doughnuts at Sugar Shack Are Now Vegan

    • Oh yeah! I hope they spread nationwide. LOVE vegan donuts!

    • on August 10, 2017
  • Re: Almost All of the Doughnuts at Sugar Shack Are Now Vegan

    • I wonder if the location on Hugeunot Rd is on this bandwagon, too? I sure…

    • on August 9, 2017
  • Re: Drinking History: The Virginia Historical Society Throws Its First Craft Beer Festival

    • Sounds like a great event! Right up Richmond's alley. Looking forward to attending next year.

    • on August 9, 2017
  • More »
  • More by Robey Martin

    • 2015 State of the Plate

      2015 State of the Plate

      Favorite dishes, unsung heroes and the rise of hospitality in Richmond. Plus, why our Restaurant of the Year is Metzger Bar & Butchery.
      • Mar 10, 2015
    • Single-Minded Focus

      Single-Minded Focus

      The old Phil's Continental Lounge will transform into Jack Brown's Beer & Burger Joint in March.
      • Feb 20, 2015
    • Noodles Galore

      Noodles Galore

      Spiral Noodle is slated for opening this spring in the old Yapple spot.
      • Feb 19, 2015
    • More »

    Copyright © 2017 Style Weekly
    Richmond's alternative for news, arts, culture and opinion
    All rights reserved
    Powered by Foundation